Witness late twice to testify, judge will decide tomorrow in Tippecanoe Mall shooting trial

Erves is facing six felony charges and two misdemeanor charges for allegedly shooting a gun at a person at the Tippecanoe Mall last December.

Posted: Jul 29, 2020 10:44 PM

TIPPECANOE COUNTY, Ind. (WLFI) - Six more witnesses testified on Wednesday in the bench trial for Iyon Erves. As we've previously reported, Erves is facing six felony charges and two misdemeanor charges for allegedly shooting a gun at a person at the Tippecanoe Mall last December.

The day started off on a different note. The court had subpoenaed Carrington Boykins to testify that morning. She was ordered to be at the court at 8:30 in the morning, however she was not there and no one answered the door at her home when deputies went to get her. She eventually made it to the courthouse around 11 a.m. 

She told Judge Sean Persin that she was up late the night before tending to her son who had a fever. This became a concern for Judge Persin in connection to the current pandemic, but decided to proceed since she was there.

She testified that she knew Erves and also knew his mother from the store she owned at the mall called Dream Palace. She was questioned by police on the night of December 27th about what she saw and heard. She ended up contradicting the statement she made to police that night. 

In a video of her interview with an LPD detective in December, she said Erves told her "I hope I shot him" in reference to a minor he was allegedly aiming at. However while sworn in under oath in court, she repeatedly denied Erves told her that. She said she did not remember what she told police that day. 

Judge Persin had to break for lunch at noon for another scheduled hearing. He said he wanted her home with her son since he was sick, even though the state was not done questioning him. She said she would check her email for notification of when she should return and that she would be able to get to the courthouse in time. The state said after the lunch break they sent an email around 1:20 p.m. saying she needed to be back at the courthouse at 2:15 to finish her testimony.

Judge Persin also called the Tippecanoe County Health Department to get their guidance on how they should proceed. He said having witnesses testify remotely was problematic and he didn't want to deal with that in this case. Boykins did not show up at 2:15 and the court went into recess for 45 minutes.

She was brought to the courthouse around 3:15. Judge Persin said, per the health department's advice, everyone in the courtroom had to wear a mask regardless of social distancing. Boykins said she had been tested for coronavirus but it was negative and felt fine. Every person entering the courthouse also had their temperature taken and if it is below 100 degrees, you are allowed to enter. The reason she gave for being late a second time was that her phone had died.

The state continued questioning her about the video. She said she remembered other things Erves had said to her that day, but remained adamant that she could not confirm her words in the video with LPD. Judge Persin ultimately did not allow the state to admit the video as official evidence.

Since Boykins was late in the morning, they decided to move forward with other witnesses who were there. A fifth minor who was part of the friend group involved in the incident testified first. He confirmed much of what the other minors testified yesterday. However, he said he did not see the gun being pulled out or shot, because he ran away as soon as the shooter reached for something in his waistband. He said he heard what sounded like multiple gunshots, but was unsure on the amount.

Officer Keifer Mikels with LPD testified next. He said he is the one who found a gun, several unspent bullets and an unattached magazine in the storage room of the Dream Palace. Officers arrested Erves in that store, which was owned and operated by his mother. The state played Officer Mikels' body camera footage showing him finding the items.

Officer Kevin Cooney with LPD is a crime scene technician who responded to the scene that night. The state showed photos he had taken of a car in the parking lot that was damaged. He confirmed it was recent damage that was consistent with a gunshot. He was able to recreate the trajectory of the gunshot. When asked if it was possible that the gun could have been pointing upwards and still done the same damage, he responded that he did not believe so.

Officer James Jarrett with LPD testified next. He was the first officer to take a statement at the scene from the alleged victim, who is a minor. In a portion of body camera footage presented by the state, you see the victim and two female minors standing near the Dream Palace. Those two females testified yesterday. The victim points into the store saying the shooter was in the store. Neither the state nor the defense called the victim as a witness and it is unclear why that is the case.

Jarrett said in his testimony that the victim appeared "shaken up" and "scared." In the video, you see the camera pointed towards the group. You see the victim perk up as he sees someone off camera. He yells several expletives and says, "you're going to jail." The video continues with Officer Jarrett questioning the three minors, but Judge Persin ends the usability of the video after he yells the expletives under the law rule of excited utterance.

Jarrett's testimony was interrupted when Boykins finally arrived at the courthouse in the morning. His body camera video was played in the afternoon when his testimony resumed.

Erica Gilbert took the stand next. She is a forensic firearms examiner with the Indiana State Police laboratory. She confirmed that the casings found at the scene matched the gun Officer Mikels found in the storage room of Dream Palace. 

Finally, Detective Michael Humphrey with the Lafayette Police Department testified last. He got the consent of Erves' mother to search her store. He confirmed the location of the store in the mall, which matched previous testimony given by others. He also investigated possible security camera footage. He said there were cameras inside Dream Palace, but they were not working. He said there were no cameras on the outside of the mall at that time either.

The state then rested its case and the defense called no witnesses. Erves decided to uphold his right to silence and chose not to testify, and the defense rested its case. Both began closing arguments.

Judge Persin acknowledge that there was plentiful evidence that proved Erves was in fact the shooter. What the state is really trying to prove is the intent to kill as part of the attempted murder charge. 

The state said that multiple witnesses testified to seeing the shooter's arm fully extended and aimed at another person. They argued that someone does not pull out and aim a gun in the first place unless their intention is to kill. They also added the fact that multiple shots were fired in rapid succession shows intent to kill. 

Also, it was first agreed that the group would go outside so Erves and the victim could fight. The state argued if Erves had intended to only fist fight, then he would have stood closer to his target. However, multiple people testified that Erves stood back out of arms reach of anyone else in the group. The state said that he knew he intended to pull out his gun and had no intention of physically fighting.

The defense argued that multiple witnesses said the group was running away at or around the time Erves pulled out the gun and fired the first shot. Yet even though people were running away, people testified that Erves did not move his body to follow someone who might be a moving target. 

The defense argued that the amount of space between the group members actually shows that he did not want to kill anyone because a target further way is less likely to be struck. The defense said the state had not proved other counts of attempted battery and intimidation, and that at best, the state had only proved criminal recklessness. 

The state responded that someone doesn't have to actually testify to being scared. Merely the act of running away from a gun proves fear and intimidation.

The state and defense finished closing arguments around 4:45 in the afternoon. Judge Persin said he wanted to use the night to look over his notes and review testimony before making a guilty or not guilty verdict. Erves told his family members in the gallery that he loved them as he exited the courtroom in handcuffs with a baliff escort. The court will reconvene at 9 a.m. on Thursday for the final verdict.

West Lafayette
Overcast
49° wxIcon
Hi: 55° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 49°
Kokomo
Overcast
46° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 44°
Rensselaer
Clear
41° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 41°
Fowler
Clear
41° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 41°
Williamsport
Overcast
47° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 47°
Crawfordsville
Broken Clouds
46° wxIcon
Hi: 55° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 46°
Frankfort
Overcast
49° wxIcon
Hi: 56° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 48°
Delphi
Overcast
45° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 45°
Monticello
Overcast
45° wxIcon
Hi: 53° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 45°
Logansport
Overcast
45° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 45°
Rainfall is ahead for Thursday!
WLFI Radar
WLFI Temps
WLFI Planner

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 166564

Reported Deaths: 4194
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion26255795
Lake14627362
St. Joseph9725171
Elkhart9402142
Allen8741232
Hamilton6462117
Vanderburgh622464
Tippecanoe402416
Porter355450
Hendricks3442137
Monroe337538
Johnson3307131
Delaware314475
Clark308565
Vigo280641
Madison254796
LaPorte241464
Cass230125
Kosciusko210329
Warrick206865
Floyd188468
Howard170166
Bartholomew149058
Marshall149028
Dubois147926
Wayne145533
Grant135440
Henry134330
Boone131050
Hancock125044
Noble124535
Jackson122519
Dearborn103828
Morgan100440
Lawrence99238
Gibson95612
Clinton93516
Daviess93236
Shelby91835
Knox83910
LaGrange82815
Harrison80724
Fayette79021
Putnam78317
DeKalb78111
Posey7787
Jasper7075
Miami6905
Steuben6748
Montgomery64422
White63016
Greene58138
Adams5777
Scott55916
Decatur53339
Whitley4926
Ripley4888
Wells47311
Clay4697
Sullivan46714
Starke4608
Wabash4599
Huntington4545
Orange42525
Spencer4236
Randolph42110
Fulton3956
Washington3923
Jennings38813
Franklin38325
Perry37714
Jefferson3655
Pike36318
Jay3486
Carroll34713
Fountain3393
Tipton28523
Vermillion2761
Parke2604
Rush2544
Blackford2425
Newton24011
Owen2171
Martin2040
Pulaski1794
Crawford1651
Brown1503
Ohio1367
Union1180
Benton1110
Switzerland990
Warren921
Unassigned0236

COVID-19 Important links and resources

As the spread of COVID-19, or as it's more commonly known as the coronavirus continues, this page will serve as your one-stop for the resources you need to stay informed and to keep you and your family safe. CLICK HERE

Closings related to the prevention of the COVID-19 can be found on our Closings page.

Community Events