Arguments begin for fatal hit-and-run crash, tow truck driver testifies

Yariel Butler's trial started on Monday. Robert Carley was the tow truck driver involved in the crash. As the only eyewitness to the crash, he took the witness stand in the first day of testimony.

Posted: Feb 3, 2020 7:18 PM
Updated: Feb 4, 2020 6:29 PM

LAFAYETTE, Ind. (WLFI) - Twelve jurors are now hearing the arguments in a fatal hit-and-run case. Yariel Butler is facing three charges: two counts of leaving the scene of an accident resulting in death, and one count of leaving the scene of an accident resulting in bodily injury.

It happened early in the morning of August 1st, 2018. Court documents say that Kimberly McDole was driving on State Road 28 when she drove through the intersection with U.S. 52 and crashed into a cornfield. Documents say that McDole left the scene and came back with her friend, William "Eric" Peacock, for help.

They called for a tow truck and Robert Carley arrived to help. Carley testified on Monday in court. He said he did a single-lane recovery since there is no sizable shoulder on U.S. 52 and since there are multiple lanes on the road. This means his truck was parked at an angle in the right-hand lane to help protect him while he worked. He said this is a standard practice that he had been trained to do. He also confirmed that he had multiple lights flashing on his tow truck and that he was wearing reflective gear.

He said he pulled McDole's car across U.S. 52 to safety and walked back so they could do paperwork. He told the court the last thing he remembered was walking around the back of his truck with McDole and Peacock nearby. That's when he originally told police that a vehicle swerved to the right of the truck, striking all three people. 

The prosecuting attorneys played Carley's 911 call. You can hear him saying that the other two people with him are not moving and that the vehicle left the scene.

Lakeisha Murdaugh and Russell Brown are representing Butler. Murdaugh gave the opening statement for the defense. She said she is concerned about blame and teenage stereotypes as potential biases in this case, seeing as Butler was 18-years-old at the time of the crash.

She said Butler was on her way home from working the 12-hour night shift at NHK in Frankfort. The HR manager for NHK testified on Monday and confirmed that Butler clocked out of her shift at 4:11 a.m. on August 1st and video surveillance video shows her driving off the NHK property around 4:13 a.m. Court documents say police responded to Carley's 911 call and arrived on scene of the crash around 4:30 a.m.

Murdaugh also emphasized that there was a dense fog advisory that morning and that having the tow truck parked in the lane of traffic was dangerous to begin with. She is arguing that Butler thought she had been sideswiped in her lane of traffic, and that's why she didn't stop. She said Butler did not see any lights or people before the crash or afterward in her rearview mirror. 

Peacock was pronounced dead at the scene. McDole died on August 27th due to her injuries. Carley only suffered some serious bruising to his legs.

Murdaugh said Butler then went home, looked at her car and spoke with someone who advised her to call her insurance. The insurance people then asked if she had filed a police report, which she hadn't. This is where Murdaugh is arguing the youth stereotype, saying that many young drivers don't know the proper protocol for a car accident and that Butler didn't know she had to stop and file a police report even though it's the law to do so. 

She said once her client realized what she had to do, she did file a claim with her insurance and went back to another 12-hour shift at NHK the following day. When Officer John Dale pulled Butler over on August 2nd, she admitted to being in an accident and voluntarily disclosed the location. 

Prosecutors said in their opening statements that Butler should have reasonably anticipated the accident considering the weather conditions. Carley testified that it was clear but dark when he first arrived to help McDole and Peacock, and was unsure when the fog started. He also said he remembered other cars passing them safely in the other northbound lane.

Pictures taken by police for evidence show the fog while it was still dark outside and that the tow truck lights were on. Carley also admitted that he did not use any other type of safety signals at his disposal, such as reflective triangles for the road or the use of a road flare.

The trial is expected to go until Thursday at the latest. News 18 will continue to be in the courtroom bringing you the latest updates from this trial on-air and online.

West Lafayette
Clear
74° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 74°
Kokomo
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 70°
Feels Like: 73°
Rensselaer
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 72°
Fowler
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 89° Lo: 70°
Feels Like: 72°
Williamsport
Scattered Clouds
74° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 74°
Crawfordsville
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 70°
Frankfort
Scattered Clouds
75° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 75°
Delphi
Scattered Clouds
75° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 75°
Monticello
Scattered Clouds
75° wxIcon
Hi: 93° Lo: 70°
Feels Like: 75°
Logansport
Scattered Clouds
72° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 70°
Feels Like: 72°
WLFI Radar
WLFI Temps
WLFI Planner

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 48524

Reported Deaths: 2698
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion11682684
Lake5180242
Elkhart330146
Allen2798132
St. Joseph196466
Cass16389
Hamilton1563101
Hendricks1410100
Johnson1288118
Porter73237
Tippecanoe7268
Madison65964
Clark65544
Bartholomew58644
LaPorte58026
Howard57757
Kosciusko5494
Vanderburgh5486
Marshall4904
Noble48228
Jackson4723
LaGrange4709
Hancock45035
Boone44543
Delaware44550
Shelby42625
Floyd38144
Morgan32931
Monroe30028
Grant29526
Montgomery29420
Clinton2892
Henry27415
Dubois2736
White26510
Decatur25032
Lawrence24625
Dearborn23823
Vigo2358
Harrison21822
Warrick21829
Unassigned193193
Greene18932
Miami1832
Jennings17611
Putnam1698
DeKalb1624
Scott1627
Daviess14317
Wayne1406
Orange13623
Perry1299
Steuben1292
Franklin1248
Jasper1212
Ripley1177
Wabash1122
Carroll1102
Fayette997
Newton9810
Starke933
Whitley925
Gibson812
Huntington812
Randolph794
Wells731
Fulton721
Jefferson722
Jay680
Washington671
Pulaski661
Knox640
Clay604
Rush583
Adams501
Owen491
Benton480
Sullivan451
Posey420
Brown391
Spencer381
Blackford372
Crawford320
Fountain322
Tipton321
Switzerland270
Parke230
Martin220
Ohio170
Vermillion140
Warren141
Union130
Pike110

COVID-19 Important links and resources

As the spread of COVID-19, or as it's more commonly known as the coronavirus continues, this page will serve as your one-stop for the resources you need to stay informed and to keep you and your family safe. CLICK HERE

Closings related to the prevention of the COVID-19 can be found on our Closings page.

Community Events