The GOP's older voter problem

Is the GOP having a senior moment?Late summer surveys by CNN and other organizations show senior vote...

Posted: Sep 19, 2018 2:57 PM
Updated: Sep 19, 2018 2:57 PM

Is the GOP having a senior moment?

Late summer surveys by CNN and other organizations show senior voters tilting decisively towards Democratic congressional candidates. That would dramatically reverse the recent pattern in midterm elections when the elderly provided a major boost to GOP candidates.

2014 Midterm elections

2016 Presidential election

Conservatism

Continents and regions

Donald Trump

Elections (by type)

Elections and campaigns

Electoral districts

Florida

Government and public administration

Government bodies and offices

Government organizations - US

Legislation

Midterm elections

North America

Phil Bredesen

Political candidates

Political Figures - US

Political organizations

Politics

Society

Southeastern United States

Tea Party movement

The Americas

United States

US Congress

US Democratic Party

US Federal elections

US federal government

US House elections

US House of Representatives

US political parties

US Presidential elections

US Republican Party

US Senate

US Senate elections

Voters and voting

White House

In CNN surveys conducted in early August and early September, registered voters who are 65 years of age and up preferred Democratic congressional candidates to Republicans by margins of 20 and 16 percentage points, respectively. CNN is not the only news organization to report this kind of GOP deficit among seniors. A late August Washington Post-ABC News survey found that if older voters were casting their ballots today, they would back Democratic candidates for the House of Representatives over Republican candidates by a whopping 22-point margin, 57% to 35%. Similarly, a national poll by Marist College conducted in early September found that among voters 60 years of age and up, they favored Democratic congressional candidates by a 15-point margin.

This is a potentially huge problem for Republicans: In the 2010 and 2014 midterm elections when Republicans regained control of the House and Senate, respectively, GOP candidates were solidly backed by voters 65 and up. When Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate in the 2006 midterm elections, they had a narrow advantage among senior voters.

Historically, Democrats were seen as the party of seniors. President Franklin Roosevelt made Social Security one of the landmark accomplishments of the New Deal. Decades later another Democratic president, Lyndon Johnson, would push health care coverage as an entitlement for the elderly and make Medicare one of the cornerstones of his Great Society program. In subsequent elections as social issues came to the fore, seniors have tended to split their votes more evenly or side with Republicans. But in 2010 with the rise of the Tea Party and the generational and societal change ushered in by the presidential election of Democrat Barack Obama, elderly voters turned decidedly towards the GOP. Republicans helped drive that process by asserting that president Obama's 2010 signature health care reform legislation would defund Medicare. And that would be a GOP rallying cry throughout the Obama presidency.

While exit polls showed that senior voters backed Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton for president in 2016, since he's been in office, polls suggest Trump has had difficulty maintaining elderly voters as a pillar of the Republican coalition.

Seniors are customarily more risk-averse than younger voters. Upheaval and uncertainty in government policies can make older voters apprehensive. They tend to prefer a safe and steady pair of hands to guide the ship of state. In many instances, Donald Trump has governed in an opposite manner. And his brash personal style can sometimes come across as reckless.

At the start of his term in office, CNN polling found older Americans gave president Trump fairly good job approval ratings. But that began to change with the chaotic and unsuccessful efforts by Trump and Congressional Republicans to repeal Obamacare. Elderly voters may not have been enthusiastic about the legislation to begin with, but the GOP's helter-skelter push for repeal proved equally problematic.

Trump created upheaval

Midterm elections are almost always a verdict on the incumbent president and the fortunes of Republican House and Senate candidates will ebb and flow with perceptions of Trump. By spring and early summer of this year, CNN polling found seniors fairly closely divided when asked in the so-called "generic ballot" question whether they supported the Democratic or GOP candidate in the midterm elections. At the time, Trump was not engaged in pitched battles with Congress, and he was seen to have de-escalated tensions with North Korea in the run-up and aftermath of his summit with its mercurial leader Kim Jong Un in early June.

That stasis didn't last long. When Trump took to the world stage in July, he seemed to scrap the traditional role of the U.S. president as the steady leader of the western democracies. After a contentious NATO summit in Brussels, Trump strained the "special relationship" between the U.S. and Great Britain when he undercut British Prime Minister Theresa May, telling a London newspaper that she had mishandled Brexit negotiations and speculating that her Conservative Party rival Boris Johnson might make a good prime minister. Lastly, at a summit with Russian president Vladimir Putin, Trump came across at a press conference as weak and vacillating and his performance was panned by both congressional Democrats and Republicans.

Shortly after Trump returned home, he once again adopted tough tactics for dealing with Congress, warning that he would be willing to see a government shutdown if appropriations legislation failed to include adequate funding for a border wall with Mexico and other stricter immigration measures. That is the kind of brinksmanship at which many voters, but especially seniors, can recoil. Not surprisingly, in subsequent CNN polls on the midterm elections, elderly voters abandoned Republicans and embraced Democrats.

"Older voters are much more reliable than younger ones, and if they are moving away from Trump or less likely to turn out because they don't like the way he has conducted his presidency, that is a real problem for the Republicans," observed Karlyn Bowman, a veteran public opinion analyst at the American Enterprise Institute. Trump's antagonism towards Sen. John McCain, the Arizona Republican, even after his death, may have compounded this GOP predicament. "McCain is someone seniors can relate to," said Bowman.

Older voters in key races

If older voters continue to side with Democrats, it's even more likely that they will capture enough House seats to regain the majority in that chamber. There are seniors in every House district, but some places where Republicans could be particularly vulnerable to a Democratic upset are:

  • Forida's 18th Congressional District (Palm Beach, Martin and St. Lucie counties), held by first-term Rep. Brian Mast
  • Florida's 6th Congressional District (Daytona Beach), an open seat formerly held by GOP gubernatorial nominee Ron DeSantis
  • Arizona's 8th Congressional District (suburban Phoenix), won by Republican Debbie Lesko in a special election in April
  • Michigan's 1st Congressional District (the Upper Peninsula and the northern tip of the state), represented by first-termer Jack Bergman.

All four of these seats are considered "Likely Republican" in CNN's Key Race ratings, but all four also have a senior population (65+) of more than 20%.

But it may be in the midterm Senate contests where this trend could have its most profound impact. Democrats have six potentially vulnerable Senate incumbents: Florida's Bill Nelson, Indiana's Joe Donnelly, Missouri's Claire McCaskill, Montana's Jon Tester, North Dakota's Heidi Heitkamp and West Virginia's Joe Manchin. President Trump carried those last five states by double-digit margins in the 2016 election, and he is a frequent presence in Florida, where he narrowly bested Hillary Clinton and maintains a Palm Beach retreat.

Four of those states, Florida, Montana, North Dakota and West Virginia, are among the top ten states with the highest proportion of elderly (65+) residents according to the last decennial census. (Missouri was ranked 16th and Indiana ranked 33rd.)

All of those Democratic incumbents have been elected before, and in Nelson's case, he's won three previous Senate races. They are known quantities, and if elderly voters in those states decide to look for a check on Trump, they have a familiar face to cast a ballot for.

If all of these endangered Democratic incumbents are able to win reelection and the party doesn't lose any other seat it currently holds, Democrats will only need to pick up two GOP Senate seats to claim a majority. Among the leading prospects for Democratic pick-ups are Republican seats in Arizona (ranked 18th in senior population), Nevada (44th) and Tennessee (29th). But in these contests, Democrats have a lot more than just the percentage of seniors going for them. In Arizona and Nevada, there are bulging Hispanic populations that are likely to produce droves of Democratic voters who oppose Trump's hardline immigration stance. In these two states, a good performance among elderly voters could tip the balance to the Democratic candidates.

And in Tennessee, Democrats are counting on former two-term governor Phil Bredesen to capture the seat of retiring Republican Sen. Bob Corker. Democrats hope that strong showings in urban and suburban areas in recent elections will continue for Bredesen in places like Nashville (where he was once mayor), and other major Tennessee metros. Of course, many of the new voters in those bustling areas may not have even lived in the state when Bredesen won his last election in 2006. That's why it's important for him to cut into traditional Republican bastions in rural and small town Tennessee. Those kinds of places tend to have a disproportionate share of older voters. Bredesen carried every county in the state when he was reelected governor 12 years ago, and presumably there are still rural and small town voters in Tennessee who can recall casting a ballot for him. They could be the margin that enables him to prevail.

Of course, polls can vary a lot between now and Election Day, and Democrats may not be able to sustain the hefty margins they're currently receiving from seniors in several polls. But to win back the House and the Senate, they probably don't need to. As the 2006 election showed, even a narrow margin of victory among elderly voters can help facilitate a Democratic takeover of Congress.

West Lafayette
Overcast
69° wxIcon
Hi: 85° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 69°
Kokomo
Broken Clouds
70° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 59°
Feels Like: 70°
Rensselaer
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 54°
Feels Like: 68°
Fowler
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 68°
Williamsport
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 68°
Crawfordsville
Overcast
67° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 67°
Frankfort
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 68°
Delphi
Overcast
69° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 69°
Monticello
Overcast
69° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 69°
Logansport
Overcast
70° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 70°
Quiet Conditions After Yesterday's Storms.
WLFI Radar
WLFI Temps
WLFI Planner

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 74992

Reported Deaths: 3044
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion15963725
Lake7632275
Elkhart488385
Allen3937163
St. Joseph354682
Hamilton2803104
Vanderburgh199713
Hendricks1901108
Cass17969
Johnson1767118
Porter133839
Clark124447
Tippecanoe122111
Madison98765
LaPorte92130
Howard90565
Kosciusko86212
Bartholomew80147
Floyd79146
Marshall79022
Monroe75930
Delaware73852
Dubois70012
Noble68429
Boone68346
Hancock67038
Vigo66810
Jackson5885
Warrick58630
LaGrange55910
Shelby55827
Grant52830
Dearborn50828
Morgan48334
Clinton4403
Henry38520
Wayne37710
White37210
Montgomery35421
Lawrence35027
Harrison34123
Decatur33832
Putnam2908
Miami2742
Daviess27320
Scott26810
Greene25134
Jasper2452
Franklin24314
DeKalb2354
Gibson2284
Jennings22612
Steuben2113
Ripley2087
Carroll1932
Fayette1907
Perry18612
Starke1787
Posey1770
Orange17324
Wells1712
Wabash1703
Fulton1692
Jefferson1652
Knox1590
Whitley1546
Tipton14311
Washington1421
Spencer1363
Sullivan1341
Clay1245
Huntington1243
Randolph1234
Newton11810
Adams1022
Jay920
Owen911
Pulaski831
Rush804
Brown741
Fountain742
Blackford652
Ohio655
Benton620
Pike560
Vermillion550
Parke521
Switzerland520
Crawford450
Martin450
Union410
Warren231
Unassigned0206

COVID-19 Important links and resources

As the spread of COVID-19, or as it's more commonly known as the coronavirus continues, this page will serve as your one-stop for the resources you need to stay informed and to keep you and your family safe. CLICK HERE

Closings related to the prevention of the COVID-19 can be found on our Closings page.

Community Events