Germaine Greer's dangerous ideas about rape

For someone who's spent most of her life advocating for other people, Germaine Greer appears to have very little inte...

Posted: Jun 3, 2018 3:24 PM
Updated: Jun 3, 2018 3:24 PM

For someone who's spent most of her life advocating for other people, Germaine Greer appears to have very little interest in other people's feelings.

This week, at the Hay Festival of literature and arts in Wales, the 79-year-old author of "The Female Eunuch" and vocal figurehead of second-wave feminism claimed that we shouldn't think of rape as "a spectacularly violent crime," but as 'bad sex ... where there is no communication."

Greer suggested a more lenient approach to punishing rape, perhaps "200 hours of community service," or an 'R' tattoo on a man's hand, as suitable penance.

"Why not believe the woman and lower the penalty?" Greer asked. 'If we are going to say, 'Trust us, believe us,' if we do say that our accusation should stand as evidence, then we do have to reduce the tariff for rape."

She cited her own survival of rape at 19 as testimony that it really isn't that bad, calling rape "something that leaves no sign, no injury, nothing."

"I wasn't that angry," she stressed.

Earlier this year, Greer also drew outrage with remarks around the #MeToo movement. She told The Sydney Morning Herald: "If you spread your legs because he said, 'Be nice to me and I'll give you a job in a movie,' then I'm afraid that's tantamount to consent, and it's too late now to start whingeing about that."

Where to begin.

These would all be strange things for anyone to say, let alone someone who has famously identified as a feminist for the past six decades. But they are far more than that: They are dangerous.

If, for example, rape is not that serious, as she asserts, then how are women's feelings about it to be taken seriously? As someone so invested in women's freedom, why would Greer place the burden of men's crimes -- as they are in her eyes -- on women's shoulders? If women are to value and treasure their bodies, free of shame, the violation of those bodies must be intolerable.

Her suggestion that we should demur because the prosecution of rape is difficult is curiously at odds with a career spent pushing back against establishment ideas. And at bottom, her statements make no sense.

Why is believing the victim of a crime -- whom Greer assumes is female -- incompatible with a proportionate penalty for the aggressor? A common whine of #MeToo decriers is the statistic that between 2% and 4% of accusations of sexual assault are false. The proportion of false accusations of murder and theft is the same, yet that contingent has yet to suggest we reduce sentences for those offenses.

So why cast doubt on rape victims, when the burden of proof is the same, and the odds of painting a target on your back for ridicule and abuse if you speak up far greater? "Prove you didn't give him your wallet voluntarily," said no one, ever.

If, as Greer suggests, the issue of consent is so hazy, then permanently inking rapists with an R is a weird contradiction. It's also a dangerous idea. If someone is predisposed to violence enough to rape, it's not out of the question they'd go further to silence someone entirely, rather than risk being identified later.

And if, having committed a grotesque act, a rapist genuinely repented and rehabilitated, branding them would impede their assimilation back into the community. So why bother? It's as medieval a suggestion as saying that wives should just grit their teeth and take it every time their husband wants sex and they don't.

The explanations Greer gives as to why many people feel more pain than she does over rape are outdated ideas of feminism.

She told the Hay audience, where she was speaking in advance of the publication of her forthcoming book "On Rape": "You might want to believe that the penis is a lethal weapon and that all women live in fear of that lethal weapon. Well, that's bull****. It's not true. We don't live in terror of the penis. ... A man can't kill you with his penis."

This is laughably gendered. Men are raped too, and some women have penises. But like so much that is out of sync with her view of the world, Greer is happy to dismiss the transgender community, who are especially vulnerable to sexual assault, and likewise the idea that a person's attitude to rape isn't a corollary of their attitude to sex and gender.

Fear of rape and fear of sex are distinct: Sex is the result of a willing decision, and rape isn't. Plenty of people who have been raped have enjoyed sex -- when it's not rape.

"Every time a man rolls over on his exhausted wife and insists on enjoying his conjugal right, he is raping her. It will never end up in a court of law," Greer told the audience.

But that's just the point -- sex with another person is no one's "right," one to be "insisted" upon. When it is, that is an infringement of the other person's rights, and it is the law's job to protect those.

Like any form of violence, rape treads a strange line between impersonal and intimate. It is an act that has everything to do with the perpetrator's incapacity for compassion, and nothing to do with the victim's. But people have very different reactions to being violated, and that is wholly personal.

Violence may be brutish but it isn't always physical, and it reverberates as much in the mind of the recipient as the body, if not more. Greer's assertion that the severity of rape is related to the "'susceptibility," as she would have it, of the victim is an alarming confusion. Rape is severe, and people respond to things differently. As Greer herself points out, communication during sex is of the essence, and so, it should follow, is communication around sex, and rape.

The dismissal of someone's experience as just "bad" is actively damaging. Survivors' feelings are theirs to bear, but the weight of the crime is absolutely not. The aftershock of an event that saw their body treated as disposable can be compounded if their feelings later are as well.

There's less distance than we'd like to acknowledge between the thoughts "I'm making a fuss about nothing," and "I am nothing." The unwillingness to take someone seriously could be the difference between trauma that heals, and trauma that doesn't.

Greer seems to have conflated strength with never having been hurt in the first place - as though the only way to claim ownership of a situation is to say that there is no situation.

Her head is deep in the sand, and offering a poor view of contributions besides her own.

West Lafayette
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 34°
Kokomo
Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 34°
Rensselaer
Cloudy
37° wxIcon
Hi: 39° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 31°
Fowler
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 40° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 34°
Williamsport
Cloudy
41° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 34°
Crawfordsville
Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 20°
Feels Like: 32°
Frankfort
Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 32°
Delphi
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 36°
Monticello
Cloudy
40° wxIcon
Hi: 45° Lo: 24°
Feels Like: 36°
Logansport
Cloudy
37° wxIcon
Hi: 41° Lo: 23°
Feels Like: 31°
A few showers, then much warmer weather is ahead...
WLFI Temps
WLFI Planner

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 1084488

Reported Deaths: 17386
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion1425562217
Lake705171220
Allen64347862
Hamilton49481481
St. Joseph48135639
Elkhart39011536
Vanderburgh33874494
Tippecanoe29863271
Johnson26876463
Hendricks25548379
Porter24683380
Madison20440444
Clark19785275
Vigo18609308
LaPorte16638260
Monroe16237217
Delaware16230286
Howard16181310
Kosciusko13763162
Hancock12644184
Bartholomew12544188
Warrick11889189
Wayne11794264
Floyd11792225
Grant11484233
Morgan10134188
Boone9576120
Noble8921121
Henry8917163
Marshall8792146
Dearborn875798
Dubois8673138
Shelby7958127
Cass7907126
Lawrence7861182
DeKalb7416106
Jackson738093
Huntington7280107
Gibson6922118
Montgomery6830122
Harrison680696
Knox6779113
Steuben641185
Miami6384106
Whitley631160
Putnam626582
Clinton614176
Wabash5958108
Jasper591991
Jefferson5617102
Ripley540892
Adams527881
Daviess4964116
Scott475978
Wells462998
White459967
Greene458399
Clay452162
Decatur4491109
Jennings434666
Fayette429094
LaGrange413890
Posey398344
Washington380654
Randolph3770107
Fountain364962
Spencer353446
Fulton352270
Starke343672
Sullivan342454
Owen341676
Orange320270
Jay315450
Rush293332
Carroll287037
Franklin283544
Perry281453
Vermillion277557
Parke244930
Tipton244664
Pike241744
Blackford213944
Pulaski203158
Newton176552
Brown169850
Crawford167129
Benton160517
Martin149219
Switzerland143712
Warren131416
Union115416
Ohio90513
Unassigned0581

COVID-19 Important links and resources

As the spread of COVID-19, or as it's more commonly known as the coronavirus continues, this page will serve as your one-stop for the resources you need to stay informed and to keep you and your family safe. CLICK HERE

Closings related to the prevention of the COVID-19 can be found on our Closings page.

Community Events