The researcher at the center of the Cambridge Analytica data-mining scandal touted controversial techniques at a lecture four years ago in Russia, despite downplaying the methods in an email to colleagues after his work attracted international scrutiny.
The Soviet-born researcher, Aleksandr Kogan, started working with Cambridge Analytica in 2014. That same year, he teamed up with students and researchers from St. Petersburg State University, one of the top schools in Russia, to pursue a data-harvesting project similar to the one that produced the data he sold to Cambridge Analytica.
Kogan provided data on tens of millions of Americans to SCL Group, the parent company of Cambridge Analytica, which worked on the Trump campaign.
Facebook has accused him of violating platform policies by passing Facebook user data he gained through an app on to third-parties, including Cambridge Analytica. The tech giant also said Kogan lied to them about the true nature of his work by claiming the app was for academic research and not commercial use, something Kogan denies.
For his partnership with the university, Kogan traveled to Russia three times. In lectures to students, according to videos reviewed by CNN, he painted a different picture than what he told colleagues in a recent email in which he downplayed his work.
In the email, Kogan said he gave a few lectures at St. Petersburg State University "on how social media data CANNOT be used effectively to make individual-level predictions." He also said in the email that the predictions he gave SCL were just as likely to be wrong as they were to be right.
After this story was first published, Kogan said in an email to CNN, "Back in 2014, I gave quite a few talks about big data methods and what they are useful for. In these talks, I discussed both my own research and that of others. When speaking about the accuracy of the results--like understanding people better than their friends and family understand you--I was quoting research done by others in this space. But over the course of the next year, as I started to personally delve into the issue of prediction accuracy, I found the claims to have been grossly inflated. What we found ourselves was that the data isn't very accurate at the individual level at all. And so my talks in subsequent years started to reflect this. In fact, my 2016 talk in Russia talked about how I found that for any complex trait (like personality), we couldn't predict people well at all."
Kogan used to speak in glowing terms about the power of data from Facebook. He told the students in one May 2014 lecture, delivered in Russian, that data gleaned from social media unlocks key insights.
"The level of what can be predicted about you based on what you like on Facebook is higher than what your wife would say about you, what your parents or friends can say about you," Kogan said. "Even if we take your 10 best friends and they all give a description of who you are as a person and we combine it all together - this analysis method is still better."
"Your Facebook knows more about you than any other person in your life," he added.
Kogan told the students that "basically everything" about someone could be predicted from Facebook "likes" alone, including someone's intelligence, personality and well-being.
He said the data could be captured at a low price - "quick and cheap, this almost didn't cost anything" - and that such methods had the potential for major commercial benefits.
The research conducted in Russia, in association with Kogan, included informed consent requirements that are standard for academic research. In the lecture, Kogan described how his app pulled information about likes, friends, ages, demographics - and more private details.
"It's messaging... this is private information, which no one sees," Kogan said. "You can also load all of that. We usually load 3,000 (messages) per person. And there they talk about everything."
It's not clear whether Kogan was boasting to eager students or if he actually accessed and saved private messages of some Facebook users.
"Four years ago, our Platform policy permitted people to share their own message inbox with developers," a Facebook spokesperson told CNN on Tuesday. "...Developer access to messages was enabled only if the person downloaded the app and explicitly approved the permission."
That feature was phased out in 2015, the spokesperson said.
In the email to his colleagues, Kogan decried recent reports about his work in Russia, and denied being a "Russian spy." He said his position at St. Petersburg State University was "mostly an honorary role" and that he only visited the school three times.
A person familiar with Kogan's work corroborated parts of his email, explaining that the St. Petersburg students saw Kogan as a "token Westerner" who could help them secure funding for their research. It's more likely projects get approval with backing from Western academics, the person noted.
Previous reports suggested that Kogan got a grant directly from the government for his project. But the university is given a pool of money from Russia's federal budget, and the school then decides which specific research projects get funded, the person familiar explained.
"At some point, he confused the role of academic researcher and businessman," the person said of Kogan's work with Cambridge Analytica. "Maybe he was too young and did something stupid with his data. He didn't come across as this evil, scheming individual."
The techniques Kogan used to harvest Americans' data for Cambridge Analytica are drawing scrutiny on both sides of the Atlantic. But they were not a secret while they happened: The Russian team, which pursued a separate research project, published an academic abstract online in March 2015 that detailed similar data-harvesting methods.
The press office for St. Petersburg State University did not have any comment on Tuesday.
- Cambridge Analytica researcher touted data-mining in Russia speech
- Cambridge Analytica announces closure
- Your guide to Cambridge Analytica
- Cambridge Analytica anuncia su cierre
- Cambridge Analytica files for bankruptcy
- Cambridge Analytica claims audit will confirm it deleted Facebook data
- Facebook announces forensic audit of Trump data firm Cambridge Analytica
- Facebook user sues over Cambridge Analytica data scandal
- Facebook investigating employee's links to Cambridge Analytica
- Massachusetts AG to investigate Facebook, Cambridge Analytica