STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Thomas, conservatives impatient at Supreme Court's inaction on 2nd Amendment

What's the Supreme Court done about the 2nd Amendment lately? Not much, to the deep frustration of Justice Clarence T...

Posted: Feb 23, 2018 1:16 PM
Updated: Feb 23, 2018 1:16 PM

What's the Supreme Court done about the 2nd Amendment lately? Not much, to the deep frustration of Justice Clarence Thomas.

Thomas, joined by two of his colleagues, the National Rifle Association and many gun rights supporters believe that lower courts are thumbing their nose at a landmark 2008 Supreme Court opinion holding that the 2nd Amendment protects an individual's right to keep and bear arms.

Just this week, Thomas blasted the lower courts for what he described as a cavalier attitude toward the 2nd Amendment.

The landmark opinion -- District of Columbia v. Heller -- was penned in 2008 by the late Justice Antonin Scalia. Supporters of gun rights thought that after that opinion, and a follow up two years later, lower courts would begin striking down gun regulations across the country.

But in large part, that has not happened. Some judges have pointed to Scalia's own words in Heller: "The right secured by the 2nd Amendment is not unlimited."

Thomas, in an opinion released on Tuesday, criticized the courts for a "general failure to afford the 2nd Amendment the respect due an enumerated constitutional right." He was writing a dissent after his colleagues declined to take up a challenge to California's 10-day waiting period as it applies to individuals who already own guns.

"The lower courts are resisting this court's decision" in Heller, Thomas complained, "and are failing to protect the 2nd Amendment to the same extent that they protect other constitutional rights."

The 69-year-old justice also turned to his own colleagues on the bench bemoaning the fact that there haven't been the necessary four votes to take up a major 2nd Amendment related case since Heller.

"If a lower court treated another right so cavalierly, I have little doubt that this court would intervene," Thomas said. "The 2nd Amendment is a disfavored right in this court."

No other justice joined Thomas's dissent in the California case, but conservative Justices Neil Gorsuch and Samuel Alito have chimed in with similar sentiments concerning other cases.

Adam Winkler, a professor of law at UCLA School of Law, says the justices might be holding off before granting another significant 2nd Amendment case because there hasn't been enough disagreement in lower courts to merit stepping in.

"The Supreme Court often stays its hand until there is a deep division in the lower courts," he said in an interview. "So far they have been relatively uniform in their interpretations."

But the court's inaction frustrates gun rights supporters.

"Historically, the Supreme Court has been lax in enforcing the 2nd Amendment and that is exactly why people who care about 2nd Amendment rights have been very active politically, because they know they can't always count on the courts to protect that part of the Constitution," said David Kopel, a University of Denver law professor who supports gun rights.

Kopel points to the fact that just before Scalia suddenly died in early 2016, he too felt like the lower courts weren't taking his opinion seriously. In December 2015, Scalia joined a dissent from denial penned by Thomas in a case concerning a Chicago suburb's ban on some semi automatic firearms and magazines. The two justices criticized the lower court's "crabbed" reading of Heller.

In a 2016 opinion, Alito, joined by Thomas, wrote a concurrence in a case regarding stun guns.

"The lower court's ill-treatment of Heller cannot stand," Alito said.

That same year, Thomas, who almost never speaks from the bench at oral arguments, stunned the audience by asking a series of questions. They were related to the 2nd Amendment.

And Scalia's replacement, Gorsuch, joined Thomas last spring when the court declined to take up a case concerning the right to carry firearms in public.

Winkler notes another reason there hasn't been the necessary four votes to take up a 2nd Amendment case: Justice Anthony Kennedy, the court's swing vote on so many hot button issues, was in the majority in Heller.

"One of the great mysteries is how Anthony Kennedy would rule on future 2nd Amendment cases," said Winkler " If the liberal justices thought Kennedy would vote with them to limit the scope of the 2nd Amendment they would eagerly take one of these cases," he said.

Several of the cases have been brought by lawyers for the NRA. Indeed, the court on Tuesday declined to take up the group's challenge to a California law that imposes fees on firearms transactions.

On Thursday, Wayne LaPierre, the group's executive vice president and CEO, spoke before a conservative crowd addressing the recent shooting in Parkland, Florida.

"Some people out there think the NRA should just stick to its 2nd Amendment agenda, and not talk about all of our freedoms," he said. "But real freedom requires protections of all of our rights, and a 2nd Amendment isn't worth its own words in a country where all of our other individual freedoms are destroyed," he said.

In his comments, LaPierre didn't mention the Supreme Court or the fact that it is in the midst of a momentous term. The court is contemplating cases concerning free speech, abortion related restrictions, privacy and religious freedom. But there is no 2nd Amendment case on the docket.

In his opinion on Tuesday, Thomas wrote that cases concerning "abortion, speech and the Fourth Amendment are three" of the Court's favored rights. "The right to keep and bear arms," he said, "is apparently this Court's constitutional orphan."

West Lafayette
Clear
53° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 53°
Kokomo
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 44°
Rensselaer
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 63° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 48°
Fowler
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 48°
Williamsport
Clear
50° wxIcon
Hi: 66° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 47°
Crawfordsville
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 67° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 45°
Frankfort
Clear
47° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 46°
Delphi
Clear
49° wxIcon
Hi: 65° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 47°
Monticello
Clear
49° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 47°
Logansport
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 46°
Spotty Showers Early, followed by Cooler Temps and Breezy NE Winds.
WLFI Radar
WLFI Temps
WLFI Planner

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 108646

Reported Deaths: 3478
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion20341757
Lake10013312
Elkhart6198106
St. Joseph586796
Allen5785198
Hamilton4600109
Vanderburgh318126
Hendricks2607120
Monroe224336
Johnson2241122
Tippecanoe211313
Clark205056
Porter197843
Cass19209
Delaware180159
Vigo169621
Madison153075
LaPorte134837
Floyd127961
Howard125163
Kosciusko116717
Bartholomew113257
Warrick104134
Marshall97423
Boone93846
Dubois92118
Hancock89242
Noble86432
Grant85132
Henry73424
Jackson7259
Wayne72214
Morgan68038
Shelby65529
LaGrange62811
Daviess61627
Dearborn61428
Clinton59111
Harrison54824
Putnam5098
Lawrence49928
Montgomery49421
White47114
Knox4659
Decatur44739
Gibson4344
DeKalb42511
Miami4202
Greene40935
Fayette40413
Jasper3732
Scott34410
Steuben3447
Sullivan32612
Jennings30512
Franklin29225
Posey2900
Clay2855
Orange27924
Ripley2768
Carroll26713
Wabash2547
Washington2491
Whitley2456
Wells2422
Starke2387
Jefferson2363
Adams2303
Fulton2292
Tipton21522
Huntington2073
Randolph2047
Perry20014
Spencer1984
Jay1640
Newton16411
Owen1621
Martin1560
Rush1484
Pike1331
Vermillion1210
Fountain1152
Pulaski1121
Blackford1072
Crawford980
Brown933
Parke902
Benton880
Union760
Ohio757
Switzerland660
Warren381
Unassigned0225

COVID-19 Important links and resources

As the spread of COVID-19, or as it's more commonly known as the coronavirus continues, this page will serve as your one-stop for the resources you need to stay informed and to keep you and your family safe. CLICK HERE

Closings related to the prevention of the COVID-19 can be found on our Closings page.

Community Events